• Follow us


Childless workers often lose out on tax credits. Not with this program.

The Earned Income Tax Credit has moved millions of Americans out of poverty – and it’s won some bipartisan support because it assists the poor without discouraging work. People in low-wage jobs can get an income boost through tax credits, even if they owe no income tax.

Now, some lawmakers hope Congress can expand the program, which currently does little for workers without dependent children. And some small-scale experiments are showing what that might mean for reducing inequality.

A nonprofit effort called Paycheck Plus has been tested since 2014 in New York City and Atlanta. It is helping to ease the bite of poverty for people like Keith Hardrick, who qualified for a payout of $1,500 to supplement his wages of $12,000 last year.

But researchers say tax credits are at best a partial fix for bringing people from the sidelines into the labor force. “Tax incentives are a good thing ... but they’re not going to solve the problem of getting people into the labor market and training up their skills,” says Lawrence Katz at Harvard University.


After Keith Hardrick quit his job last year as a school social worker, his income took a dive. As he figures out his next career move, he’s tapped into the gig economy, recharging electric scooters for a startup company in Atlanta. All told, he earned around $12,000 in 2018.

But this year’s tax season smiled on Mr. Hardrick. Not because of President Donald Trump’s tax cuts, which mostly accrue to corporations and high earners, but because he had enrolled in a three-year experimental program that tests what happens when single workers on low incomes receive more generous annual tax refunds.

In the first two years, Mr. Hardrick didn’t see any benefits because his income was too high. This time, though, he qualified for a payout of $1,500. He plans to use the money to change residences this month, and to set up his new place while paying some bills.

“It helps people who need a little extra,” he says of the program, as he sits at the nonprofit On The Rise Financial Center. “It’s like a stimulus package.”

The program in Atlanta mimics the Earned Income Tax Credit, a federal initiative that is credited with moving millions of families out of poverty by providing a supplement to low wages.

Unlike that program, however, it is targeted not at parents but at adults without dependent children, who get the short end of the EITC stick. By doing so it fits squarely into the national debate over how to reduce inequality while promoting work and responsibility in an era of often-stagnant wages. It’s a debate that animates the crowded left field of Democratic presidential aspirants and other officeholders, as well as conservatives who see EITC as a pro-work policy that is preferable to welfare.

“Not every policymaker loves it but it does have broad support,” says Caroline Schultz, a senior associate at MDRC, a New York-based nonprofit that ran the EITC-style program in Atlanta and New York in partnership with public and private organizations.

Potential bipartisan appeal 

Proposals to expand the $71 billion EITC have come from both sides of the aisle. In 2016, President Barack Obama and House Speaker Paul Ryan both called on lawmakers to change the tax code so that workers who aren’t raising children can qualify for more cash. The EITC is a “refundable” tax credit, meaning it can provide a benefit to people even if they owe no federal income tax. The Obama and Ryan proposals would have raised the maximum refund and phased it in more quickly. But Congress left the EITC unchanged when it passed the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act signed by Trump.

Since then, Democrats in Congress have drafted ambitious anti-poverty bills that lean on the EITC for fiscal redistribution. The GAIN Act, with big increases for qualifying families and for single adults like Mr. Hardrick, has been sponsored in the Senate by Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, and in the House by Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif. And Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., has also proposed an expansion of the EITC and other refundable tax credits, including for middle-class families.

“There’s good reason to think we haven’t exhausted the benefits of the program,” says Hilary Hoynes, a professor of public policy and economics at the University of California, Berkeley who has studied the EITC’s effects on the poverty and health of low-income families.

The EITC dates back to 1975 but has since been expanded several times under Republican and Democratic presidents. Many states also offer refundable tax credits for low-income filers, with varying degrees of generosity.

The toolkit for reducing inequality 

Of course, this is just one way to address inequality. Experts say that if the U.S. wants to help people near the bottom of the income ladder, a range of approaches can help, from raising minimum wages to offering targeted support for things like housing, transportation, or education. But many also say programs like EITC fill an important role, boosting incomes without making it more expensive for people to be hired or discouraging them from working.

Under the federal code, a single mother with two children can claim a credit of up to $5,828 for 2018, with the benefit phased out above $46,703. However, low-income adults without dependent children have a much lower income cut-off ($15,570) and stingier payouts.

This was the group that MDRC recruited for its program, called Paycheck Plus. In New York, it assigned 6,000 childless adults at random into two groups. From 2014, the first group of 3,000 was given assistance with filing their tax returns and could claim the existing credits. The second group was told about Paycheck Plus, helped to file tax returns, and offered a maximum refund of $2,000 with eligibility of up to $30,000 in income, on top of any state and federal credits that they received.

In Atlanta, where the program began in 2015, there were 2,000 workers assigned to the control and 2,000 to Paycheck Plus groups. All refunds were paid after the IRS tax deadline in April.

Low-paid workers often cycle in and out of eligibility for programs like EITC as their incomes and family situations change. Policymakers usually try to phase out benefits so that workers don’t face a sharp cut-off that could discourage them from taking jobs or working longer hours.

“Any program you want to target to low-income people you have to phase out in some manner. So there’s always concern that people would cut back,” says Cynthia Miller, a senior fellow at MDRC and lead author of a 2018 evaluation of the New York trial.

In New York, MDRC found that enrollees in Paycheck Plus had higher after-tax earnings and saw a reduction in severe poverty compared to the control group. Noncustodial parents, typically men, were more likely to make child support payments when they got bonuses.

(In Mr. Hardrick’s case, he has two school-aged children who live with their mother. He says he doesn’t have to make support payments but contributes to their household budget.)

A boost in employment? Partially.

MDRC researchers point to an encouraging uptick in employment of disadvantaged men in New York. This category of workers, which includes men who were formerly in jail or prison, have largely fallen out of the formal labor market, says Ms. Miller of MDRC. “There’s a lot of interest in [the question of] how do we pull them back in?”

Still, with the exception of these disadvantaged men, the overall effect of the New York program on male employment was zero, whereas female workers responded across the board by working more, giving a modest boost to overall employment rates, up 1.9 percentage points.

This isn’t a surprise, says Lawrence Mead, a professor of politics and public policy at New York University. Women tend to respond better to pro-work incentives like the EITC, which was part of President Bill Clinton’s 1990s welfare reforms, of which Professor Mead was a prominent supporter.

He’s skeptical that tax refunds can have the same effect on men, particularly those who don’t live with their children, and advocates mandatory requirements for welfare that force more men to take employment. “The idea that incentives cause men to go to work is false,” he says.

Lawrence Katz, an economics professor at Harvard University and co-author of the MDRC report, says he had expected to see modest gains in employment led by women. He was pleased to see a demonstrated cut in poverty. “Among programs to help a group of hard-working, low-income individuals it seems to do a reasonable job of transferring money,” he says.

And while the bump in work for disadvantaged men was positive, he agrees that it will likely take more than the promise of tax refunds to significantly increase their employment. An expanded EITC combined with occupational training and other labor-market interventions would be a more effective pro-work way to tackle poverty.

“Tax incentives are a good thing and they’re easy to implement, but they’re not going to solve the problem of getting people into the labor market and training up their skills,” says Mr. Katz.

Help for tight family budgets

For Shakira Hightower, a parent liaison at an elementary school in Atlanta, her cash bonus from Paycheck Plus has helped her to develop a side project from her full-time job. She is setting up a nonprofit to help professional families in her community. On her current salary of $23,000, she qualified for a $1,300 payout for the past two years and she expects a similar amount this time.

Ms. Hightower is a single mother with two sons who are in college, so she no longer receives the EITC benefit paid to custodial parents. But she lives on a tight budget and says that Paycheck Plus has been a welcome boost.

MDRC plans to publish its findings from Atlanta this summer. Ms. Schultz says Atlanta’s results may differ since its economy has lower wages and a cheaper cost of living than New York.

The reality remains that one in five workers earned less than $11.40 an hour in 2017. For full-time workers that is the equivalent of $22,800 a year. The EITC can bolster incomes and lure some workers back into the labor market, but even some fans say it’s no substitute for other steps to ensure that labor gets a bigger share of the economic pie.

Get the Monitor Stories you care about delivered to your inbox.

“If you’re already a minimum wage worker working full-time, the EITC is going to reduce your poverty but not change your employment rate,” says Ms. Hoynes, who sits on an advisory board at MDRC.

“At the end of the day,” she says, “we’re trying to identify policies to increase wages – and earnings.”

Read More

Leave A Comment

More News

Business & Finance

Eugene Arhin Donates To Muslims At Awutu Bawjiase 2019-05-22 06:06:52 The Communication Director of the Jubilee House, Eugene Arhin, who was accompanied by some constituency executives of the governing New Patriotic Pa

GhIPSS Want Direct Debit To Collect Funds 2019-05-22 06:06:52 Organisations or service providers who take funds from customers regularly have been urged to explore Direct Debit to ensure that they have a more e

Asky Airlines Boost Technology To Enhance Delivery Services 2019-05-22 06:06:52 Asky Airlines has launched its app to make enhance service delivery to the flying public. The application which can be found on the Google play stor

Ethiopian Airlines, Ghana End Deal For New Carrier 2019-05-22 06:06:52 Ethiopian Airlines and the government of Ghana have signed a strategic partnership agreement to set up a new national carrier in Accra, Ghana. Ethio

NPP Begins 'Operation Reduce NDC Votes' 2019-05-22 06:06:52 The ruling New Patriotic Party (NPP) has launched what it calls ldquo;Operation 50/50 Campaign rdquo; in the Affigya Kwabre South Constituency of th

Sack CID Boss—Families Of Kidnapped Takoradi Girls 2019-05-22 05:36:38 The families of the three Takoradi kidnapped girls are demanding the removal of the Director-General of the Criminal Investigations Department (CID)

Chereponi: One Killed, 13 Arrested In Reprisal Attack 2019-05-22 05:36:38 Atleast 13 persons have been arrested following reprisal attacks in Chereponi in the North East Region. Confirming this on Eyewitness News, the Nort

I Can’t Rig Elections – Jean Mensa 2019-05-22 05:36:38 ldquo;It is not possible to rig the elections, even if my father is running for President, rdquo; The Chairperson of the Electoral Commission (EC),

A/R: 9-Year-Old Girl Missing After Downpour In Tafo 2019-05-22 05:36:38 A nine-year-old girl from Tafo in the Ashanti region is reportedly missing after Monday 39;s heavy rains. The about two-hour rains led to flooding i

V/Region: 54-Year-Old Man Arrested For Killing Wife 2019-05-22 05:36:38 The Ho municipal police command has arrested a 54-year-old man who allegedly killed his wife in Hordzo, a suburb of Ho last Thursday. Emmanuel Dorfe

AFCON 2019: Prez. Akufo-Addo Backs Kwesi Appiah's Decision 2019-05-21 19:00:48 President Akufo-Addo has backed Coach Kwesi Appiah 39;s decision to hand over the Black Stars captaincy to a different player. Asamoah Gyan in a sta

Deschamps plays down Mbappé award comments 2019-05-21 18:48:09 France boss Didier Deschamps on Tuesday refused to become entangled in the fall-out of Kylian Mbappé's comments during an award ceremony in


Cash-strapped Portland’s board sacks CEO Nkeri 2019-05-21 13:47:54EAPCC has sacked its managing director, Simon Peter ole Nkeri.

Rotich to unveil mortgage refinance company today 2019-05-21 13:47:10Major shareholders include the Treasury, the World Bank, commercial banks, deposit-taking savings and credit cooperative societies (saccos) and micro-

Ex-Chase Bank boss gave firms linked to him 2019-05-21 13:46:48Mohammed Zafrullah Khan did not repay the loans advanced to Colnbrook Holdings Limited and Camellia Investments Limited between 2012 and 2015.

Mayfair Bank narrows loss in first quarter to 2019-05-21 13:44:49Mayfair Bank's interest income rose 90.5 percent to Sh126.1 million as the loan expanded five times to Sh3.4 billion from Sh677.7 million.

Ride-hailing firm Bolt hires Jumia executive 2019-05-21 13:44:05Bolt has tapped Jumia’s global head of logistics and operations, Olaoluwa Akinnusi, to be the firm’s new country manager.

Administrators move to sell fashion retailer Deacons 2019-05-21 13:43:21Deacons East Africa have moved to sell the company in a bid to raise funds to settle its liabilities.

StanChart’s first quarter profit up 31pc to Sh2.4bn 2019-05-21 13:42:48StanChart’s profit growth is the highest among the big banks that have so far published their first quarter results.

South Africa tech firm cleared to buy iWayAfrica 2019-05-21 13:42:13Echotel International Proprietary has received the green light from the CAK to acquire 80 percent of iWayAfrica Kenya.

Stock decline hurts HF’s share-based pay scheme 2019-05-21 13:41:34HF’s stock rout on the Nairobi bourse has hurt its share-based compensation scheme.

Man at centre of gold swindle locked in 2019-05-21 13:38:07KCB bank accuses the politician of defaulting on the car loan he took five years ago.

Jared Otieno, 15 others charged in fake gold 2019-05-21 13:36:35The accused persons will however remain in custody until May 27, awaiting a pre-bail report.

China could open market for fresh produce 2019-05-21 13:34:41China has hinted at plans to open its market for more fresh produce from Kenya.

Reuters: Business News

U.S. judge rules Qualcomm practices violate antitrust law 2019-05-22 07:27:10Qualcomm Inc unlawfully suppressed competition in the market for cellphone chips and used its dominant position to impose excessive licensing fees, a

British Steel goes into liquidation after failing to 2019-05-22 07:26:08British Steel, the country's second largest steel producer, has collapsed after failing to secure emergency government funding, jeopardising some 25,

British Steel owner Greybull: We worked hard to 2019-05-22 07:25:32British Steel's owner Greybull Capital said on Wednesday it had worked hard to keep Britain's second largest steel producer alive but that the chall

UK has agreed an indemnity for British Steel 2019-05-22 07:24:41Britain has granted an indemnity to the official receiver handling the collapse of British Steel, the country's second largest steel producer, Prime

Huawei unwanted: Asian shops shun phone trade-ins on 2019-05-22 07:18:53Mobile phone retailers in some Asian countries are refusing to accept Huawei devices for trade-ins, as more consumers look to offload their device on

British Steel is open to new buyers: UK 2019-05-22 07:16:22British Steel, which was forced into liquidation on Wednesday after failing to secure an emergency government loan, is open to new buyers, business mi

Lowe's cuts full-year profit forecast as higher costs 2019-05-22 07:11:09Lowe's Cos Inc cut its full-year profit forecast and reported disappointing first-quarter earnings on Wednesday, as higher costs and a push to catch

Target quarterly results trounce estimates on higher online 2019-05-22 06:59:42Target Corp's same-store sales and profit for the first quarter beat Wall Street estimates on Wednesday, benefiting from higher online sales and an i

Exclusive: Behind Grindr's doomed hookup in China, a 2019-05-22 06:51:39Early last year, Grindr LLC's Chinese owner gave some Beijing-based engineers access to personal information of millions of Americans such as private

French government: Ascoval rescue deal not impacted by 2019-05-22 06:50:08A rescue deal for the Ascoval steel plant in northern France is not impacted by the current woes at British Steel since the Ascoval transaction involv

In Fed policy review, labor may finally win 2019-05-22 06:42:33At 2.3 percent, Minneapolis' jobless rate seems impossibly low, even with national unemployment at a 50-year trough.

Exclusive: Walmart to make first direct pitch to 2019-05-22 06:32:53Walmart Inc will meet large consumer goods companies and advertising firms for the first time in New York next week to pitch its advertising business,

Business - The Huffington

On Puerto Rico’s 'Forgotten Island,' Tesla's Busted Solar 2019-05-11 08:00:02After Hurricane María plunged Vieques into darkness, Tesla's arrival heralded the dawn of a microgrid future. But it wasn't that easy.

Balloon Pops On 45 Party City Stores Amid 2019-05-10 18:26:26The company blames the closures on "market and economic changes that naturally arise in the business.”

U.S. Hikes Import Taxes On $200 Billion Of 2019-05-10 01:21:34Beijing has already vowed to retaliate, escalating a battle over China’s technology ambitions and other trade strains.

Amazon Faces Another Claim It Discriminated Against Workers 2019-05-09 15:55:51Three Muslim employees have filed a federal complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Amazon Allegedly Fired 7 Pregnant Warehouse Workers For 2019-05-07 12:01:21A new CNET report surfaced several lawsuits filed against Amazon alleging that the tech giant failed to accommodate the workers' needs and later fire

Muslim Man Was Fired When He Spoke Up 2019-05-04 05:45:17"I know you’re a Muslim and I will do my best to treat you right," Wali Omarkheil's manager allegedly told him during their first meeting.

United Blocks Cameras Installed In In-Flight Entertainment Months 2019-04-26 20:21:13The company says the cameras are disabled and were installed on the in-flight screens as a standard feature by the manufacturer.

Elon Musk, SEC Settle Dispute Over Telsa CEO's 2019-04-26 17:49:39Musk is now required to get prior approval from Tesla’s legal counsel for public statements, including tweets, about the company’s finance

Facebook Expects FTC Fine Could Hit $5 Billion 2019-04-24 17:24:27A Federal Trade Commission investigation into possible privacy violations could yield a steep fine.

Home Page

India's drug regulator warns patients against faulty Medtronic 2019-05-20 13:33:05India's CDSCO has advised patients to seek immediate medical assistance if they feel dizzy, light-headed, severe short breath or loss of consciousnes

US, China trade war will push world towards 2019-05-20 13:18:58Reserve cut US interest rates back to zero within a year if the world economy heads to recession, says Morgan Stanley.

Kamal Nath says he is ready for floor 2019-05-20 12:42:28He said the BJP was talking about instability of the Congress-led government as it wanted to save itself from getting "exposed" on its erstwhile cor

From McAloo to Egg Wrap, McDonald's drops several 2019-05-20 10:50:59Besides, the menu boards, tray mats, and packaging have a new design to be consistent with McDonald's simple, modern brand identity

India adopts new standards for measuring kilogram, kelvin, 2019-05-20 10:45:34Over 100 countries have adopted the metric system of measurements, also known as the International System of Units (SI), which has been in practice si

Investor wealth soars Rs 5.33 trillion as exit 2019-05-20 10:36:29In the forex market, the rupee strengthened and was trading higher by 58 paise to 69.65 against the dollar

Young and unsettled: Millennials and Gen Z pessimistic 2019-05-20 09:46:42Only about half of both groups aspire to purchase a home, and even fewer desire to start a family, says Deloitte survey.

Amitabh Bachchan is most trusted celebrity; Virat leads 2019-05-20 09:20:45The Most Trusted Personality 2019 report lists the most trusted individuals across three different fields

Amul hikes milk prices by Rs 2/ltr in 2019-05-20 08:46:28Prices will go also up in Gujarat, West Bengal, Kolkata, Uttaranchal, Maharashtra, and other places.

BJP to meet allies, discuss new govt after 2019-05-20 08:18:26Party president Amit Shah will hold discussions with National Democratic Alliance Partners at BJP HQ in Delhi.

ArcelorMittal tells NCLAT it will pay Rs 42k 2019-05-20 07:43:12The debt-ridden Essar Steel has alleged foul play, saying that vital facts have been suppressed by ArcelorMittal which would have rendered them inelig

Sensex vaults 1,422 pts, most in 10 years, 2019-05-20 06:37:09All that happened in the markets today

Christian Science Monitor |

This Nebraska Republican says it’s time to think 2019-05-11 19:19:25President Trump is meeting with Democrats on infrastructure. Rural America says that, from roads to internet access, it needs to be part of any plan.

A doubly green deal? Clean energy jobs also 2019-05-11 19:19:25New analysis from the Brookings Institution suggests that transitioning to clean energy sources could open up a range of high-paying career paths.

NYC, largest fur market in country, considers ban 2019-05-11 19:19:25If passed, New York would become the third major American city to ban the sale of fur. Industry advocates argue the ban will trigger the loss of more

Taxpayers need help. So does the IRS. 2019-05-11 19:19:25The IRS budget has been cut 17% since 2010, even as the tax code has grown more complicated. Enforcement and customer service are strained.

Border crisis delays truckers hours, sometimes days 2019-05-11 19:19:25President Donald Trump has beefed up border security, but with inspectors assigned elsewhere, trucks crossing into the U.S. with goods from Mexico for

In debt or struggling to save? Artificial intelligence 2019-05-11 19:19:25With friendly names like “Charlie,” the latest financial apps use algorithms to analyze spending habits and give advice. But they’re

Why capitalism in America now needs its defenders 2019-05-11 19:19:25Capitalism or socialism? At a Monitor Breakfast Wednesday, Larry Kudlow defended capitalism as the best path to prosperity for all.

‘Too cozy.’ Boeing crashes raise doubts over FAA 2019-05-11 19:19:25The crash of Boeing 737 Max jetliners in Indonesia and Ethiopia have prompted reviews not just of the airplane but of regulators’ approval

Rural America faces housing cost hardship 2019-05-11 19:19:25Over the past decade, nearly a fourth of U.S. rural counties have seen a sharp increase in households spending half or more of their income on housing

Childless workers often lose out on tax credits. 2019-05-11 19:19:25A tax-refund initiative in Atlanta showcases a type of welfare program that can reduce poverty without discouraging work.

Legal pot: Why minorities say they’re being left 2019-05-11 19:19:25Black lawmakers from New York to Georgia threaten to block marijuana legalization unless there are concessions for drug-war scarred neighborhoods.

Trapped in tariffs, firms tied to lobster industry 2019-05-11 19:19:25From tariffs on lobsters to duties on the steel in lobster traps, here’s how one U.S. industry is affected by trade tension with China and Europ

Disclaimer and Notice:WorldProNews.com is not responsible of these news or any information published on this website.